Do I Want a Heat Pump or an AC?
Not sure which cooling (and maybe heating) solution is right for you? Take this quick quiz to find out!
What This Quiz Considers
This quiz evaluates seven factors that determine whether a heat pump or a traditional air conditioner is the better fit for your home:
Your local climate
Homes in milder climates get the most year-round value from a heat pump. In regions with extreme cold, a heat pump may still work well, but pairing it with a backup heating source is often the practical choice.
Your heating and cooling needs
If you need both heating and cooling, a heat pump handles both in one system. If you only need summer cooling and already have a furnace you’re happy with, a standalone air conditioner may be all you need.
Energy efficiency priorities
Heat pumps transfer heat rather than generate it, which can use significantly less energy than traditional systems. If efficiency is a top priority, that tends to point toward a heat pump.
Upfront cost vs. long-term savings
Heat pumps typically cost more upfront but may reduce your energy bills over time. Air conditioners usually have a lower initial price point but only provide cooling.
Environmental impact
Heat pumps produce fewer direct emissions, especially when powered by clean electricity. If reducing your carbon footprint matters to you, this is a meaningful factor.
Your existing heating system
If you already have a reliable furnace, adding an air conditioner is straightforward. If your heating system is aging or you’d like to consolidate, a heat pump can replace both your furnace and AC in many cases.
How your province generates electricity
Heat pumps run on electricity, so they’re most environmentally effective in provinces with clean power grids (hydro, wind, solar), like Ontario, BC, and Manitoba.
Your Possible Results
Based on your answers, the quiz will recommend one of the following:
A heat pump may be the best choice for you
This recommendation applies if most of the following are true: you live in a region with moderate winters or access to clean electricity, you want both heating and cooling from one system, energy efficiency is a priority, you’re open to investing more upfront for potential long-term savings, and reducing your environmental impact matters to you. Heat pumps are especially effective in provinces like Ontario, BC, and Manitoba where electricity is primarily generated from clean sources.
An air conditioner may be the better fit
This recommendation applies if your main need is summer cooling and you already have a reliable heating system you plan to keep. Air conditioners typically have a lower upfront cost and are a straightforward addition to homes with an existing furnace. This is often the practical choice if your heating system is in good shape and you’re focused on keeping initial costs down.
You may want to weigh your options more carefully
This applies if your priorities are mixed. For example, if energy efficiency isn’t your top concern but you live in a province with clean electricity, a heat pump could still offer long-term value. Or if you’re unsure about your heating system’s condition, it may be worth having a home comfort advisor assess whether replacing both systems with a heat pump makes sense.
Frequently Asked Questions
Both systems cool your home, but a heat pump can also heat it.
-
Air Conditioner: Cools your home in warm months.
-
Heat Pump: Works as both a cooling and heating system by reversing its operation in colder months.
Consider factors like:
-
Your local climate
-
Energy efficiency goals
-
Whether you need both heating and cooling
-
Your existing HVAC setup
Our quiz can help point you in the right direction based on your needs.
Yes — modern cold-climate heat pumps are designed to perform efficiently even during Canadian winters. In extremely low temperatures, a backup heat source (like a furnace) may still be needed.
The initial cost of a heat pump is often higher, but it may provide energy savings over time since it does the job of both an AC and a furnace.
Ask us about our Smart Air Heat Pump! Also ask us if there are any heat pump rebates currently available in your area.
If you’re unsure after taking the quiz, a Reliance® Home Comfort Advisor can assess your home and help you choose the best system based on your comfort needs and budget.
An air conditioner cools your home by removing heat from indoor air and releasing it outside. A heat pump does the same thing in summer, but reverses the process in winter to bring heat into your home. In simple terms, a heat pump is an air conditioner that can also heat.
A heat pump provides both heating and cooling from a single system. In Canada, we always recommend pairing a heat pump with a backup heating source for the coldest days, but modern cold-climate heat pumps are designed to handle the majority of your heating needs year-round.
Yes. Cold-climate heat pumps are engineered to operate efficiently in temperatures well below freezing. We recommend pairing yours with a backup heating source to cover the coldest stretches, but a heat pump will handle most of your heating and all of your cooling.
Today’s heat pumps come pretty close in price to a traditional air conditioner. When you consider that a heat pump does double duty, handling both heating and cooling, you could end up ahead compared to buying separate systems. Whether it’s the right investment depends on your climate, electricity rates, and how long you plan to stay in your home.
Absolutely. A reliable furnace is actually the ideal backup heating source to pair with a heat pump. Your heat pump handles the heating and cooling for most of the year, and your furnace kicks in during the coldest stretches. If your furnace is nearing the end of its lifespan, replacing both with a heat pump and a new furnace gives you a complete, efficient system for years to come.
Yes. Heat pumps run on electricity, so their environmental benefit is greatest in provinces with clean power grids. Ontario (nuclear and hydro), BC (hydro), and Manitoba (hydro) all generate most of their electricity from clean sources, which makes a heat pump an especially strong choice in those provinces.
That’s exactly what this quiz is for. It walks you through seven quick questions about your climate, heating needs, budget, and priorities to give you a clear recommendation. If you’d like more personalized guidance after taking the quiz, a Reliance® Home Comfort Advisor can assess your specific home and help you choose the right system
This quiz is a starting point. It considers your climate, heating needs, efficiency priorities, budget, and environmental preferences to give you a general recommendation. For a personalized assessment, a Reliance® home comfort advisor can evaluate your specific home and help you choose the right system.
